Remember, you can always listen here or follow us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Either way, thanks for supporting us.
About this episode. Why can one complaint outweigh 100 compliments? Why can two people dictate the dynamics of a 60-person meeting? And why do organizations sometimes build layers of controls around risks that are vivid, memorable, or frightening, but not necessarily likely? In this episode, Zach and Hui unpack the psychology that causes organizations to give disproportionate weight to negative experiences, loud voices, bad actors, and worst-case scenarios.
Who? Zach Coseglia + Hui Chen, CDE Advisors
Full Transcript:
ZACH: Welcome back to The Better Way? Podcast brought to you by CDE advisors. Culture. Data. Ethics. This is a curiosity podcast for those who ask, “There has to be a better way, right? There just has to be.” I'm Zach Coseglia and I am joined as always by the Hui Chen. Hi, Hui.
HUI: Hi Zachary, hello everyone.
ZACH: It is just us today, but we have a really cool topic. So, Hui, why don't you go ahead and introduce it to folks?
HUI: Well, this is inspired by observations that we have made as we attend meetings. Have you ever noticed how entire meetings or entire conversations can end up being all about two people? So, you got 60 people in the room, and you plan the entire meeting based on what you think two people out of the 60 would react to what you were proposing. The other 58 don't seem to matter. And when you have the meeting, the two people drive the entire sort of atmosphere of the meeting. I was, we were just sort of struck by this phenomenon. And it pervades beyond meetings that, you know, people design programs and start thinking, but if I rolled this out, what would so-and-so say? So, this was sort of our beginning point.
ZACH: 100%. I mean, it brings back, frankly, a little bit of, you know, corporate PTSD from time spent in-house where you literally plan for the meeting by thinking about how every person in that room is going to potentially react. And then you wind up adjusting your approach to the meeting, not necessarily based on what you think is most effective to accomplish the goals that you're trying to accomplish or to get the message across in the way that's going to be clearest and most persuasive if you're ultimately advocating for something, but you're literally managing personalities in ways that get in the way of your ultimate goals. And that's just rough. And we see it all the time. And it is…
HUI: I am sure.
ZACH: And it's fully, though, applicable to our broader program. It raises questions in the compliance and culture context, like, are we governing to the loudest voices? Are we planning for the worst case scenario, not necessarily the most realistic scenario? Are we thinking too much about what the fearsome regulator or enforcement agency might say, rather than really thinking about what's in the best interest of our program? These are just some of the examples that might apply. But I do think that this happens.
HUI: I am sure everyone, as we're talking, I'm sure all of you out there listening to this, you can already picture the faces of the two people in your meetings.
ZACH: Indeed. Indeed. And like, look, we talk about this all the time from a regulatory and enforcement perspective that too often our programs sort of devolve into a, well, what's the DOJ's expectations? Or what are they going to say to us if something goes wrong? And when we focus so much on that, we wind up kind of missing the forest for the trees, which is, does our program work? Are we accomplishing our end goals rather than focusing on just like...
HUI: What do our own internal stakeholders think of things, right?
ZACH: 100%.
HUI: The DOJ that you hope you would never have to encounter as a company, worrying more about that entity than people you encounter and work with every day. So yeah, but it's actually human nature.
ZACH: It is. And that's really, I mean, that's baked into everything that we talk about. I mean, when we talk about our point of view with respect to compliance, or just managing culture more generally, we always start with human-centered.
HUI: Yep.
ZACH: It's human-centered, data-driven, evidence-based. But we start with the human because compliance is like a deeply human activity that requires some appreciation of the human psychology of what's going on within a business. One example Hui is, well, why does a single complaint often outweigh 100 compliments? I will be the first person to say, that if you give me 100 compliments, I will be so appreciative and it will make me feel very good. So I encourage you all to do that when you meet me. But if you give me one complaint, I'm going to think about it probably for at least the next couple of days. Like that one complaint is going to stick out. That's just human nature.
HUI: Every time. I mean, whether it's, you know, a post on LinkedIn, the comments you get, or you present something, the feedback you get, it always, we always focus on the one, the few that's critical and unpleasant than the one that are… the ones that are complementary. And there's actually scientific research on this from the work of Roy Baumeister. And they, you know, he talks about how negative information receives more attention, they are processed more deeply, and criticisms have disproportionate impact on decision making. And you know, the truth is, we all know, like it, you know, think about. your own experience, you know, for people out there. If you receive 99 positive emails and one negative one, which is the one that you're still thinking about at that time?
ZACH: Definitely thinking about the one. That is what I am definitely thinking about. I think most of the people listening are as well. But here's the thing, there's a variety of examples of this. There's the 100 compliments that are outweighed by the one complaint. There's the one negative e-mail that are outweighed by the 99 positive ones. There's the focus on, you know, of your, by your board on the failures rather than your successes. There's a businessperson or leader who's losing sleep over the one mistake that was made. That's okay. There's nothing wrong with this. Because, Hui, many systems, including most corporate compliance programs, are actually designed around the exceptions. They're often governed by the exceptions. And give us some examples of that beyond compliance, but also let's talk about why that's not a problem, like, we're not criticizing that.
HUI: Well, it's not a problem if you don't get carried away with it is what I would say. So, you know, like, you know, we all of us who travel by air have gone through airport security. I mean, airport security is basically a system that is designed to find terrorists. And thankfully, most people are not terrorists. But, you know they just very recently abolished the taking off shoes rule. But, you know, I remember when that rule went into place shortly after 9 11 because there was a shoe bomber. But there was one shoe bomber that then caused the rule to go into place for three decades, think about how many people, the billions of people who have to take their shoes off because of 1 shoe bomber, right? But that's how… that's how laws are made. I mean, this is one of, you know, reasons why I always say compliance is not good enough. That's why we always talk about ethics, because compliance refers to complying with laws and regulations. And laws and regulations are written for common, for the lowest common denominator. Laws don't tell you to be a good person. The law says you get punished if you kill someone or hurt someone or defraud them, but it doesn't tell you to be kind to them because that's not what the law is supposed to do.
ZACH: Yeah. And look, I mean, you provide that example of airport security and the impact that it has on billions of people. But I hear that and I'm like, you know what, I guess I'm okay with that because the consequences of an exception in that space can be truly catastrophic. That may not always be the case in the corporate compliance space. It may not always be truly catastrophic. And so, there is some amount of sort of managing to the risk. That's what we're doing. We're managing to the risk.
HUI: Yes, and it's also about understanding… having a realistic understanding of the risk. And, you know, so I recently worked on a review where this person was taking just enormous amount of steps to verify something. And I said, you know, why do you go through all this trouble? Like, I mean, you're spending enormous amount of time doing this. Well, he says, what if the list is 50%? What if this is 50% wrong? And I said, well, okay, you've been in this job for over 10 years. How many times have you seen it being 50% wrong? He said, well, a handful of times. And I said, A handful of times where they're 50% wrong? Well, let's just say it's a handful of times when it warrants returning the, you know, the application to the person. And I'm like, so you see the two levels of backpedaling that that's happening, right? In his mind, there's this exaggerated risk that it could be 50% wrong. The reality is he had never seen it. And he's not a new guy on the job, right? So a lot of times it's about not just the potential consequences, but also really the reality of the risk.
ZACH: Yeah. Well, and that's why this comes down to the second part of our common refrain, which is data-driven. So if we start at human-centered, we then find ourselves at data-driven because I worry and what I see that worries me is that we get the one example. And we then start making all kinds of assumptions about that one example rather than searching for data and evidence to understand what that one example actually tells us. And so I believe that in most organizations, the number of “bad actors” is usually pretty small. And what I feel even more confident about is that the number of known bad actors is usually pretty small. Even if you look at your robust investigative docket and you add up all of the people who are subjects in all of your various investigations across the world, you still have a fraction of a fraction of a fraction of all of your employees. But what we should be doing is being more curious and more data-driven in understanding what we know means about what we don't know.
HUI: Yes.
ZACH: So it may be that we have a small number of bad actors. But what else do we know about those people? What else do we know about the organization? How do we get answers to the questions that help us understand whether the small number of bad actors that we know about could potentially be a signal to a more pervasive, systemic, cultural, organizational issue? And so I think that in a kind of roundabout way, what we're really talking about is the assumptions that people sometimes jump to about trends without actually having data to support trends that can both undermine what the things that you know actually mean. And can also overstate what the things you actually know really mean. And the way that we combat that is with questions and data and curiosity.
HUI: Absolutely. And, you know, and that drive you to look at the landscape rather than just the tree. Look at the forest and not the tree.
ZACH: Exactly. Exactly, which is a really perfect segue into sort of the next thing on my mind, which is, we've got to recognize that the squeaky wheel does sometimes really matter. I mean, it's the foundation of what we do.
HUI: The squeaky wheel can really matter when it's really the beginning of the signal of something. Because a lot of times when we operate in an organization, lots of things are happening beneath the surface that we don't have view of. And when you see a smoke, coming out of somewhere. You kind of have to check whether there is fire.
ZACH: Yeah. I mean, that's, I mean, that was a lesson that was instilled in me very early in my compliance journey by a mutual friend of ours, Mike Friedland, who was my former boss and your former boss.
HUI: That's right.
ZACH: Who really, who taught me very early on that we get one complaint, we get one whistleblower, one hotline report. You know, we're going to be thoughtful and responsible and efficient in how we respond to it, but we're going to be deeply curious about whether or not it is reflective of something bigger. And we're going to make sure that we ask the right questions to ultimately put ourselves in a position to answer that. Is it isolated or is it not?
HUI: I had the same, of course, experience with Mike, which I love, and I cite that all the time as well. I remember having one day there was a press article in a national press about a pharmaceutical rep somewhere, and without naming the company,
and without naming the person Mike read the article. He directed me to look into whether this could be, you know, one of our sales reps. So if, you know, he was that alarmed about potential things that he was not going to overlook. That, however, is very different than building your entire program around something. And this is the distinction we're trying to make here. When you have a squeaky wheel, you want to check what is making it squeaky. That is entirely different than tossing out the wheel or buying a whole new fleet of wheels, you know, cars without squeaky wheel, whatever it is, right? The overreacting. What we're talking about here is when you see a signal, of a problem, you want to look into it and understand it deeply before you then build your whole program around it.
ZACH: Yes, yes, 100%. Let's talk a little bit about risk, because I think that there's a universally sort of accepted maxim that we want to identify and focus our attention on our greatest risks. And we want to build a program that is prioritized to address our greatest risks. But as you and I always do, it's important to define terms; and it's important to be precise about the words that we use. And there's a difference between greatest risks and most vivid risks. And there's this concept around the tyranny of vivid risks, which I think sometimes seeps into compliance programs, meaning that we mistake the vivid risk for the most significant risk. We mistake the thing that is dramatic, the thing that we can visualize most crisply with the thing that is in fact most likely, most probable, and most significant based on you know, the dynamics of our business, our industry, and the environment in which we're operating in. And there's scientific research that talks about this.
HUI: Yes, and, you know, to an extent, again, that is very logical. So, you know, take us back to the experience that we were talking about earlier, which is, you know, one is the decades of shoes off during airport security screening versus this person who is, you know, who thinks, despite his 10 years… over 10 years of experience that the applications that he reviewed may have more than 50% error. In the latter case, what is the worst thing that could happen if you had 50% error? You send it back, right, and then you have them redo. It is not the end of the world. It's fixable. Whereas if you get bombs onto an airplane, that's a vivid, that's a very vivid risk. That's the kind of risk you don't want to tolerate at all.
ZACH: Yeah, yeah. Well, it...
HUI: So, the response is proportionate in a way.
ZACH: Yeah, and it, but it also, to pick up on that example, let's talk about stuff that's happened in the last couple of years. We've had, you know, external priorities articulated around FCPA, which obviously created a tremendous amount of
activity and discussion, thought pieces, white papers, law firm alerts, conferences. I mean, we even have done podcasts and...
HUI: I'm rolling my eyes if you can't see me.
ZACH: You are. But like when we look at . . . when we look at, and I'm picking up on what we were talking about with the airplane and the shoes and the bombing, because one of the things that the administration talked about was that their focus from an FCPA perspective going forward would be on things like terrorist activity and third parties who have been designated as cartels. And again, vivid risk. I mean, we can imagine how terrible that would be if our business was doing business with terrorists or if our third-party vendor logs included, you know, drug cartels. But the flip side of that is, guys, did you need them to tell you that was a priority for you to be concerned about whether you're doing business with terrorists or if your third parties included cartels.
HUI: Exactly!
ZACH: And honestly, you know, you should know now and a year ago and 10 years ago, whether you're doing business with terrorist organizations or whether your vendor master has cartels. And the truth is, most of you 100% don't and never will. And yet the vivid nature of that risk suddenly enabled it to become something that people are talking about at conferences and writing papers about and being concerned about and rethinking their programs because of when It was really… it wasn't really the greatest risk. It was just the most vivid one.
HUI: Yeah, it wasn't really a risk, you know, for really, for most, for the vast majority of organizations. And those organizations that are regularly doing business with the cartels and the terrorist organizations don't really care about the latest guidance.
ZACH: Yeah, they're not. When you… when you send out your third party training to them, like that's the very definition of just checking a box.
HUI: Yeah, yeah. Exactly.
ZACH: Okay, so we sort of beaten that dead horse, but it's a really important question to be asking, which is, are we managing our greatest risks or are we really focusing on the risks that we can imagine? But what do we do in response? And I think that part of what we want to do in response is to ask questions like, are we treating everyone as a bad actor? We don't want to do that. We want to understand whether we're trying to regulate everyone identically. We don't really want to do that either. In fact, we talk all the time about things like training and communications really being optimized when they are customized to the person who's receiving them, when they are true to life for the person who's receiving them, when they are based on the role that the people have and the risk that they may encounter rather than being overly generic. I think we also want to make sure that we're not building from a place of distrust, but in fact, building from the perspective of building trust and engendering cooperation. And then, of course, escalating when conduct warrants not from the perspective of like a CYA, which I think is what winds up happening so often. Escalation becomes not this thing that happens when we truly need advice and counsel and guidance, but instead is coming from the perspective of, I just don't want to be held accountable for this decision. So I'm going to go and call and escalate to someone else so that it can become . . . I have someone I can point to blame in the end. So not treating everyone as a bad actor, regulating people in different ways based on role and risk, building trust and strengthening a sense of accountability.
HUI: Yeah, and I think a lot of the organizations, they build controls as if everyone is a cheater. And when you do that, you risk having really excessive and burdensome controls environments. And oftentimes, it's not just done by one department. So, it's done repetitively for different departments for their different reasons. So, you know, we have all seen vendor onboarding systems that ask overlapping questions because some, you know, compliance group wants to know about anti-corruption related questions. Another group wants to know about your privacy control. Another group wants to know about your intellectual property protection. Yet another group wants to protect something else. So, they don't coordinate. Every time they had a finding from an investigation, they add another layer of control as a result of that investigation without reviewing all the controls that's been building up in the last 10, 20 years. And each function does that in silo and impose it onto the system. Then you have a system that becomes absurd, just absurd.
ZACH: Yeah. 100%. And it also, you know, I think programs that are built from that perspective of, you know, distrust also wind up more often than not being
rigid in a way that prioritizes process over good decision-making.
HUI: Exactly.
ZACH: And by that, I mean, we wind up creating . . . oh, we've got all these things we can audit. You know, we've got exceptions to this rule, exceptions to that rule. We've got, you know, a program that focuses on, you know, black and white compliance with a set of policies, not . . . which is important, but not a program that necessarily is optimized to really understand what the behaviors mean and whether the decision making is quality and whether people understand, spot, and manage risk. We're just talking about process. And when a program focuses on process above all else, we've lost sight of the people, we've lost sight of the culture, we've lost sight of the quality of decision making. And that ultimately leads to a weaker program, but maybe one that's easier to audit, but not necessarily one that is truly effective in managing risk.
HUI: Yeah, I mean, I think ultimately, it's about shifting the mindset about, you know, what controls do we need because we assume everyone is a problem actor, to really asking how can we support good behavior while retaining the ability to address bad behavior.
ZACH: Yes, so well said. I'm not even going to add anything because that's so well said. Let's talk about a silly question. So imagine that you poll and employee population and 95% of people are satisfied. 4% of people have minor concerns from an ethics compliance culture perspective and 1% are just very upset and also highly vocal in other ways about these issues. Which of those groups do you think we should focus most on? Who should management focus on amongst those three groups?
HUI: I would say focus on all of them, but with different types of attention and different types of questions. Right. So for the, you know, for the 95% that are satisfied and content, you take stock of where they are and what you have done to have this happen, have to have this condition, this level of satisfaction, and you want to make sure that you keep it up. And you know, you also want to be mindful that if you don't understand all the conditions that are in place to achieve that satisfaction, that could change very quickly. So we want to pay that level of attention to that and that kind of attention the 4% they have, and the 1%, I would say. You, to me, I would want to understand what is driving the concern. Yeah, so what are the issues, what the root causes of their discontent may be? And that would then determine what is the next step, if any.
ZACH: I totally agree. I think this is one of those questions that, you know, it's got a kind of hidden purpose, which is to show that there isn't an answer. It's not one group. It is each group in a different way. I think about, you know, the broader conversation that we're having and about making sure that we're not overly focusing on the squeaky wheel, but that we're being aware of the squeaky wheel. And this really underscores that in a very real way, because I've heard executives say before, you know, we always have 1% of people who are just mad. So just kind of put them over there. Let's not focus on them. Well, let's, you know, understand a little bit more about what they're mad about. And we can make an assessment about kind of how credible some of those concerns are. But we should be curious about why they're so concerned and why they're so vocal. We should do the same with the 4% and, you know, with the 95%, it may not be that they're actually satisfied. It may just be that they don't feel comfortable, like the 4% or the 1% in sharing their true views. And, you know, it goes also to, I think there's a counterpart example of this that we actually talked about recently, maybe in an episode, but something that we see a lot, which is our least favorite metric around training completion and how there's this instinct to say, oh, we've got 95%, so let's focus on the 5%. I fully agree. We should ask questions about that 5%, and we talked about this, but let's also talk about that 95%. Did they take an hour-long training in 15 minutes? Because that tells you something about whether that 95% really got what you wanted them to get out of it. Did that 95% miss, you know, a lot of questions that you put in there in your quizzes and stuff, which suggested that they didn't really learn anything or if they did learn something, they weren't very concerned with getting the answer right at the end. And that also tells you something about the experience that they had. So yeah, I mean, these are complex questions. There isn't an answer. And the challenges that we're dealing with are in fact complex and require kind of a complex curiosity-driven approach.
HUI: This is what we always come back to, embracing that complexity and be curious.
ZACH: I know it is a curiosity podcast, so...
HUI: Indeed.
ZACH: All right, well, let's take this home. What are some closing reflections that you have for folks thinking about the complex topics that we've talked about today?
HUI: I think, you know, perhaps we might have framed the issues incorrectly, either at the beginning or at some point in our, you know, overall conversations outside of this podcast. The problem is not that organizations listen to squeaky wheels. The problem is then building entire programs without understanding why the wheels are squeaky. So, the problem is, lacking a reliable way to separate warning signals from noise. So it is about that, again, back to that curiosity. It's okay. In fact, I think it's our job to listen to the squeaky wheels. But we need to understand why is it squeaky? And what are the appropriate fixes to that, which may not be changing entire programs or building new initiatives? It may be something very simple.
ZACH: Yeah, yeah. I fully agree. To me, a great ethics and compliance program isn't one that is designed, as you said, exclusively around the loudest voice or the angriest stakeholder or the worst hypothetical misconduct or scenario that we can imagine.
They're designed to help organizations figure out which signals coming their way require action, which merit attention, and which concerns reveal something important about the company, about the culture, and about the system
itself. And it does, as we just said, and as we will always say, it comes down to being curious and taking a human centered, then data-driven, and ultimately evidence-based approach to everything that you do.
HUI: Absolutely.
ZACH: So, listener in closing, we encourage you to think about your own organization and ask. What receives the most attention? What receives disproportionate attention today? And should it? All right, thanks, Hui. It's always fun.
HUI: Thank you, everyone.
ZACH: And thank you all for tuning in to TheBetter Way? Podcast. For more information about this or anything else that’s happening with CDE Advisors, visit our website at www.CDEAdvisors.com, where you can also check out the Better Way blog. And please like and subscribe to this series on Apply or Spotify. And, finally, if you have thoughts about what we talked about today, the work we do here at CDE, or just have ideas for Better Ways we should explore, please don’t hesitate to reach out—we’d love to hear from you. Thanks again for listening.